Male infertility, the inability of a man to produce a pregnancy in a woman, is often caused by measurable deficits in sperm function or sperm count. In about half of all cases, however, the source of the problem is never discovered.

The good news is that, without any treatment at all, about 25% of supposedly infertile men bring about a pregnancy within a year of the time they first visit a physician for treatment. In other words, infertility is often only low fertility in disguise.

Proposed Treatments for Male Infertility

Growing, if not entirely consistent evidence, suggests that various forms of the supplement L-carnitine may improve sperm function and thereby provide benefit in male infertility.12-20,27,32,33,44-45,52

For example, in one double-blind study, 60 men with abnormal sperm function were given either carnitine (as L-carnitine 2 g/day and acetyl-L-carnitine 1 g/day) or placebo for 6 months.34 The results showed significant improvement in sperm function in the treated group as compared to the placebo group.

A similarly sized 6-month, double-blind, placebo-controlled study, which involved men with low sperm counts, found benefits with carnitine (again as L-carnitine 2 g/day and acetyl-L-carnitine at 1 g/day) taken alone or carnitine combined with the anti-inflammatory drug cinnoxicam.35

In addition, a 2-month, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study of 100 men with various forms of infertility found probable benefits with 2 g daily of L-carnitine.36

A 26-week, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial compared the effects of treatment with zinc (66 mg of zinc sulfate, supplying 15 mg of zinc), folate (5 mg), and zinc plus folate against placebo.22 A total of 108 fertile men and 103 men with impaired fertility (“subfertile men”) participated in the study. The two supplements combined significantly improved the sperm count and the percentage of healthy sperm in the subfertile men; neither supplement alone produced this effect, and there was little effect of the combined therapy on fertile men.

Another study also found potential benefit with zinc plus folate.46

For more information on dosage and safety issues, see the full articles on folate and zinc.

Mild vitamin B 12 deficiencies are relatively common in people over 60.1,2 Such deficiencies lead to reduced sperm counts and lowered sperm mobility. Thus vitamin B 12 supplementation has been tried for improving fertility in men with abnormal sperm production.

In one double-blind study of 375 infertile men, supplementation with vitamin B 12 produced no benefits on average in the group as a whole.3 However, in a particular subgroup of men with sufficiently low sperm count and sperm motility, B 12 appeared to be helpful. Such "dredging" of the data is suspect from a scientific point of view, however, and this study cannot be taken as proof of effectiveness.

For more information, including dosage and safety issues, see the full Vitamin B12 article.

Free radicals, dangerous chemicals found naturally in the body, may damage sperm. For this reason, a number of studies have evaluated the benefits of antioxidants for male infertility.

In a double-blind, placebo-controlled study of 110 men whose sperm showed subnormal activity, daily treatment with 100 IU of vitamin E resulted in improved sperm activity and increased rate of pregnancy in their partners.6

Preliminary studies suggest that vitamin C may improve sperm count and function.7 However, a recent double-blind study of 31 individuals that tested both vitamin C and vitamin E found no benefit.8 The dosages studied ranged from 200 mg to 1,000 mg daily.

According to one small double-blind study, the antioxidant carotenoid astaxanthin might enhance male fertility.37 Other antioxidants that have shown at least a bit of promise include lycopene,21coenzyme Q10,24 and selenium.25

Researchers reviewed 34 randomized trials involving 2,876 couples experiencing unexplained male infertility, as well as sperm-related problems.54 The couples in the oral antioxidant groups had increased pregnancy rates. Despite these favorable findings, the researchers concluded that these studies alone do not conclusively show that antioxidants are beneficial for male infertility.

A major pharmaceutical company has reported success for male infertility using a miscellaneous mixture of antioxidants.53 However, there is no reason to believe that the exact mixture of substances contained in this product were chosen with any particular insight; any such insight regarding the optimum formulation does not as yet exist.

Highly preliminary evidence suggests improvements in sperm function or pregnancy rates with Panax ginseng.11

The herb Lepidium meyenii ( maca) is claimed to enhance fertility, but the supporting evidence is limited to animal studies and one tiny uncontrolled study in humans conducted by a single research group.38,47-50 Contrary to what is stated on numerous websites, maca does not appear to raise testosterone levels.28

In a double-blind trial of 28 men with impaired sperm activity, use of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), a component of fish oil, failed to improve sperm health.9 Another double-blind study failed to find L-arginine effective for improving pregnancy rates.26

One very small study failed to find magnesium helpful for infertility.39

Many other substances have been suggested as treatments for poor sperm function and infertility, including the herbs ashwagandha, Eleutherococcus, pygeum, saw palmetto, and suma, as well as the supplements SAMe and calcium, but there is no meaningful supporting evidence for these treatments.

In addition, all of the treatments listed in the article on Impotence have also been proposed as treatments for male infertility, though not necessarily with any supporting evidence.

Soy or soy isoflavones,29 as well as the herb licorice,10 may reduce testosterone levels in men. For this reason, men with impotence, infertility, or decreased libido may want to avoid these natural products.

One report claims that both tea tree oil and lavender oil have estrogenic (estrogen-like) and antiandrogenic (testosterone-blocking) effects.51 If this were true, men with infertility should avoid use of these herbs. However, a literature search failed to find any other published reports that corroborate this claim.

According to a preliminary double-blind study, the supplement melatonin affects testosterone and estrogen metabolism in men, and when taken at a dose of 3 mg daily for 6 months may impair sperm function.23

Preliminary evidence from animal studies hints that use of some forms of peppermint at high doses might impair fertility.40

There is contradictory evidence from animal studies on whether the herb andrographis may impair fertility.30,31 The same is true of the herb stevia..41-43